- Nathan Carman suspected of murdering his grandfather and mother in a controversial case.
- The Netflix documentary “The Carman Family Deaths” explores the tragic events surrounding the deaths of John Chakalos and Linda Carman.
- Detailed analysis of the evidence, including Nathan’s alibis and the boat sinking incident.
- Discussion on whether Nathan’s neurodivergence influenced the criminal investigation against him.
Nathan Carman: A Suspected Tragic Killer in a Controversial Case
In November 2015, John Chakalos, an 87-year-old wealthy real estate developer, was found fatally shot at his home in Windsor, Connecticut. Three years later, on September 24, 2016, Nathan Carman and his mother Linda disappeared during a fishing trip. By November 19, 2025, the Netflix documentary “The Carman Family Deaths” had shed light on these tragic events and the subsequent investigation into Nathan’s alleged involvement in both deaths.
The Tragic Death of John Chakalos
John Chakalos, a wealthy real estate developer with an estimated net worth of $42 million, was shot at close range in his home on December 20, 2013. The police initially suspected that Nathan had committed the murder but were unable to find any concrete evidence. Nathan’s father, Clark Carman, said that their son was diagnosed with autism when he was around four years old and had a history of mental health issues.
Nathan’s Mother’s Disappearance
On September 24, 2016, Linda Carman went missing during what was supposed to be a fishing trip on her boat, the Chicken Pox. The boat allegedly sank, and Nathan managed to survive for eight days before being found in a life raft. Despite the extensive search, Linda’s body was never recovered.
Investigation and Suspicions
Nathan Carman was arrested in May 2022 and charged with his mother’s murder. Prosecutors alleged that he had murdered both John and Linda to gain early access to their inheritance. However, Nathan maintained his innocence throughout the investigation and trial preparation.
Alibis and Evidence
Nathan claimed that he was at home when his grandfather died and had an alibi for the boat sinking incident provided by surveillance video footage. Nevertheless, investigators found discrepancies in both accounts. For instance, the deputy chief of the South Kingstown Police Department, Alfred Bucco III, suggested that Nathan may have killed John Chakalos earlier than he claimed.
Neurodivergence and Investigation
Nathan’s neurodivergence was a significant factor in the investigation. His attorney pointed out that law enforcement often misinterpreted his emotional responses due to his autism, leading them to suspect him more heavily than they would with a typical individual.
Conclusion
A Complex Case of Tragedy and Suspicion
The Carman Family Deaths documentary delves into the complexities of this case, presenting both evidence supporting Nathan’s guilt and arguments for his innocence. The film leaves viewers questioning whether Nathan was truly responsible for these deaths or if there were other factors at play.
