Key Highlights
- The true story of James Garfield and Charles Guiteau is told in Netflix’s limited series “Death by Lightning.”
- Michael Shannon and Matthew Macfadyen deliver nuanced performances that humanize the figures involved.
- The series balances historical accuracy with emotional truth, creating a compelling narrative.
- Shannon portrays Garfield as a good and decent man who rose to presidency unexpectedly.
- Macfadyen’s portrayal of Guiteau is delusional yet committed, making the character engaging despite his tragic fate.
Entwining History with Modern Performances: “Death by Lightning” on Netflix
The true story of James Garfield and Charles Guiteau comes to life in Netflix’s historical limited series “Death by Lightning,” which premiered in 2023. This four-episode series delves into the forgotten history of one of America’s shortest-presidency presidents, James Garfield, and his assassin, Charles Guiteau. The narrative is a blend of factual storytelling and dynamic character portrayals that bring these historical figures to life.
Historical Accuracy Meets Stellar Performances
The series succeeds by maintaining a commitment to historical accuracy while simultaneously elevating the characters through exceptional performances. Writer Mike Makowsky, working from Candice Millard’s nonfiction book, ensures that the storytelling is grounded in fact, but the actors’ abilities are what truly bring these figures to life.
Michael Shannon as President Garfield
Michael Shannon, known for his role as General Zod in “Zack Snyder’s Justice League,” portrays James Garfield with a quiet grace. Shannon’s portrayal of the president is not just about political rhetoric; it delves into the quieter, more human aspects of the man. Garfield was a farmer and loving husband and father who rose from being a backbench congressman to the presidency through a series of unlikely events. Shannon captures this transformation with subtlety, making us appreciate the qualities that likely made him an effective leader.
Matthew Macfadyen as Charles Guiteau
Matthew Macfadyen, who gained widespread recognition for his role as Tom Wambsgans in “Succession,” brings a complex and deluded dimension to Charles Guiteau. Guiteau, driven by a sense of destiny, believed he was destined for greatness but found himself ill-equipped for the realities of political life. Macfadyen’s performance is nuanced; while his character can be seen as erratic, there is an underlying commitment that keeps viewers engaged despite knowing the tragic end.
Electric Moments and Emotional Resonance
The standout moment in the series comes in the final episode when Guiteau gains an audience with Garfield. The scene is electric, showcasing the undercurrent of energy between Shannon and Macfadyen as they portray these two very different men. Despite their brief interactions, there is a palpable tension that underscores the human drama at play.
“Death by Lightning” is not just about the events leading up to Garfield’s assassination; it’s also about how these actors can redefine historical perception and transform overlooked figures into emotionally resonant characters. The performances are what make this series worth watching, as they breathe life into a period often reduced to footnotes in history books.
Background on the Cast
Michael Shannon’s career spans decades, with notable roles including his Oscar-nominated performance in “Revolutionary Road” and his role as Superman’s enemy General Zod. His versatility as an actor is evident in his ability to play both romantic leads and antagonists convincingly.
Matthew Macfadyen has been a stalwart of the British film and television industry for over two decades. His breakout role as Mr.
Darcy in “Pride & Prejudice” cemented his status as a leading actor, and his recent turn in “Succession” further solidified his reputation. Macfadyen’s ability to play complex, emotionally troubled characters makes him an ideal fit for Guiteau’s delusional nature.
Conclusion
A Prestige Limited Series
“Death by Lightning” is a testament to the power of historical storytelling when paired with standout performances. The series showcases how great actors can elevate even overlooked figures and events, making them emotionally relevant and engaging. For fans of historical dramas or those interested in American history, this limited series offers a compelling narrative that is both historically accurate and dramatically enriching.
