Key Highlights
- The “Caryl” theory, a long-standing fan belief in a romantic relationship between Daryl and Carol from “The Walking Dead,” has been debunked.
- In the spin-off series “The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon,” a scene directly addresses the theory with Daryl and Carol firmly denying any romantic involvement.
- Actors Norman Reedus and Melissa McBride support the show’s decision to maintain their characters’ platonic relationship, emphasizing authentic storytelling over fan desires.
- The decision highlights the value of strong platonic friendships in television and the importance of respecting creative integrity.
The Walking Dead’s “Caryl” Theory Debunked: Daryl Dixon and Carol Peletier Confirm They Are Not Together
For fans of The Walking Dead, the long-standing theory that Daryl Dixon and Carol Peletier had a romantic relationship, known as “Caryl,” has been put to rest. In the latest spin-off series, “The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon” (2025), a scene directly addresses this fan theory with both characters denying any romantic involvement.
Background on Daryl and Carol’s Relationship
Daryl Dixon and Carol Peletier’s bond began in season 2 of the original The Walking Dead. Norman Reedus, who portrays Daryl, and Melissa McBride, who plays Carol, have developed a deep connection that has resonated with fans. Despite their strong friendship, the showrunners have consistently maintained that no romantic relationship existed between the two characters over 16 years.
Direct Addressing of “Caryl” Theory
In an episode of “The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon” (2025), a character named Valentina mistakenly assumes that Daryl and Carol are a couple. In response, Carol quickly clarifies her stance with the line, “Never,” followed by Daryl’s emphatic “Nope.” This scene directly confronts fan theories and confirms their platonic relationship.
Actors’ Insights on Maintaining Authentic Storytelling
Melissa McBride, in an interview with Entertainment Weekly (September 2025), shared her thoughts on the scene. She highlighted that showrunner David Zabel’s decision to include it was significant and lighthearted, suggesting a fun and unexpected moment for both fans and actors. Norman Reedus echoed these sentiments, emphasizing the importance of maintaining originality in their storytelling.
Reedus stated, “The show has never portrayed Daryl and Carol as a couple over the past 16 years. Catering to fan desires could undermine the series’ creative integrity.” He further explained that keeping their relationship platonic is crucial for authentic storytelling and respecting the characters’ history.
Value of Platonic Friendships in Television
The decision to keep Daryl and Carol’s dynamic free of romance highlights the value of strong platonic friendships in television. These relationships, such as those between Don and Peggy in Mad Men, and Sidney and Carmy in The Bear, showcase emotional depth without falling into romantic tropes often expected by viewers.
Reedus and McBride’s commitment to authentic storytelling underscores the importance of respecting fan investment while maintaining creative control. Their history dates back to season 2, with neither character ever being romantically involved throughout 11 seasons.
The spin-off explicitly refutes the “Caryl” theory, reaffirming their friendship as a significant element within the The Walking Dead universe.
In conclusion, while the “Caryl” fan theory has been shattered, Daryl and Carol’s friendship remains a powerful and impactful aspect of the series. Their connection serves as a reminder that not all relationships need to culminate in romance to be significant or meaningful.
