Movie Review: Russell Crowe and Rami Malek Face Off in the Nazi Trial Drama ‘nuremberg’

Nuremberg: A Complex Drama in Historical Context

The Nuremberg trials, a series of military tribunals held after World War II, have long been a subject for artistic exploration. In the latest cinematic take on this historic event, “Nuremberg” (Sony Pictures Classics release) offers a unique perspective by centering on U.S. Army psychiatrist Douglas Kelley, portrayed by Rami Malek.

The Role of Douglas Kelley

James Vanderbilt’s film delves into the character of Kelley, an ambitious figure tasked with evaluating Nazi leaders to ensure their fitness for trial and survival. This role is notably different from those explored in previous adaptations, such as Stanley Kramer’s 1961 drama “Judgment at Nuremberg” or the 2000 miniseries.

The Character of Hermann Göring

Russell Crowe plays the complex and charismatic Hermann Göring, a high-ranking Nazi official who becomes Kelley’s subject. The film highlights Göring’s fascinating nature as the highest-ranking living Nazi leader during the post-war period.

Conversations and Moral Complexity

The heart of “Nuremberg” lies in its exploration of conversations between Kelley and Göring, which develop a temporary understanding or even friendship. However, these interactions are marked by moral ambiguity, as they include discussions on fathers, greatness, and sometimes magic tricks.

Historical Context and Execution

The film’s narrative structure, while attempting to explore the complex ethical issues surrounding war crimes trials, is criticized for its failure to fully integrate Kelley’s character development. The courtroom scenes are filmed in a stately and sober manner, reminiscent of standard legal dramas, which some critics find lacking in depth and impact.

Supporting Cast and Ensemble

The film includes an ensemble cast featuring Michael Shannon as Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson, Richard E. Grant as the British lawyer Sir David Maxwell-Fyfe, John Slattery as the commandant of Nuremberg prison, Colin Hanks as Gustave Gilbert, another psychiatrist involved in the trials, and Leo Woodall as a German-speaking U.S. officer.

Conclusion

A Mixed Reception

“Nuremberg” is described by Lindsey Bahr, a film writer for The Associated Press, as a familiar historical drama with an expansive ensemble cast. While it provides insight into the trials and Kelley’s role, the film struggles to fully engage its audience with the moral complexities of the subject matter.