Pluribus Review: This New Sci-Fi from Breaking Bad’s Creator Is ‘one of 2025’s Smartest Shows’

Key Highlights

  • Pluribus, a new series from Vince Gilligan, stars Rhea Seehorn as Carol Sturka in an intriguing sci-fi mystery.
  • The show explores a world where people are suddenly happy all the time, blending social commentary with science fiction tropes.
  • Gilligan’s distinctive voice is evident in the mix of genuine emotions and wild plot turns, making the series both smart and entertaining.
  • Seehorn’s performance as Carol Sturka is praised for its empathy and wit, grounding the sci-fi plot in a relatable human story.

Vince Gilligan’s Return to Sci-Fi with Pluribus

The creator of the hit series Better Call Saul and Breaking Bad, Vince Gilligan, returns to the realm of science fiction with his latest project, Pluribus. This intriguing series, available on Apple TV+, is a departure from the gritty realism that defined previous works but retains Gilligan’s knack for blending the real with the fantastical.

A World Turned Upside Down

Pluribus introduces viewers to Carol Sturka (played by Rhea Seehorn), a cynical woman who lives in a world where everyone is inexplicably happy. This dystopian scenario brings to mind the works of George Orwell and Don DeLillo, with a distinct Invasion of the Body Snatchers-esque atmosphere. The show’s premise invites viewers to question how such a drastic change could occur and why it matters.

Rhea Seehorn’s Performance

Rhea Seehorn‘s portrayal of Carol Sturka is nothing short of brilliant, bringing a mix of empathy and wit to the character. Her performance is grounded in genuine human emotion, making the sci-fi elements feel both thrilling and believable. The show’s narrative shifts easily between comedic moments reminiscent of The Good Place and eerie tones similar to The Leftovers, creating a unique viewing experience.

Genre Blending and Easter Eggs

Gilligan’s approach in Pluribus is marked by his ability to blend genres seamlessly. The show evokes classic sci-fi tropes while maintaining a modern, meta-aware perspective. For example, the title of the series, with its numeral 1 instead of the letter i (Plur1bus), hints at the show’s exploration of artificial intelligence and human identity. Gilligan also pays homage to his earlier works by hiding Easter eggs in Albuquerque, New Mexico—home to Better Call Saul and Breaking Bad.

The Human Element in Sci-Fi

Pluribus is not just a science fiction show; it’s a human story. Carol Sturka, with her cynical outlook and droll wit, serves as the emotional anchor of the series. Seehorn’s performance ensures that even in a world where everyone else is happy, viewers remain invested in Carol’s journey.

A Plea for Humanity

At its core, Pluribus is a show that questions what it means to be human. The premise of people being inexplicably happy raises profound ethical and philosophical questions. Gilligan uses the sci-fi elements to explore themes of freedom of thought, artificial intelligence, and the human condition.

The series ends with a powerful statement: “This show was made by humans.” This line serves both as a commentary on the limits of AI in content creation and a reminder that even in a world where everyone else is happy, individuality and humanity remain invaluable. Pluribus is a smart, entertaining, and thought-provoking series that will keep viewers engaged until its conclusion.

Final Rating: ★★★★★