Key Highlights
- England’s game plan was predictable and failed against Scotland.
- Marcus Smith is included on the bench to provide a different option if needed.
- The decision reflects England’s reliance on a single game plan.
- Steve Borthwick’s team selection aims to adapt in case the initial strategy fails.
Rugby Strategy and the Price of Predictability
England were not just predictable; they were turgid, complacent, and seemingly unaware of Scotland’s tactics. Steve Borthwick’s side had a game plan that seemed to be a relic from an era long gone, one where territorial kicking was seen as a means to an end rather than an end in itself.
George Ford’s Game Plan
In the week leading up to England’s Calcutta Cup loss, George Ford explained his rationale behind the game plan. He dismissed the “kick for the sake of it” strategy that had characterized parts of Eddie Jones’ tenure and early Steve Borthwick’s reign. The idea was simple: kick to gain territorial supremacy and then use accurate attacking play to exploit that territory. It sounded like a South African approach, one that could make sense if it worked.
The Flawed Game Plan
But the flaw in this strategy became glaringly obvious when Scotland, led by Finn Russell, waited in ambush. England had travelled less than expected, and Ford’s game plan was laid bare for all to see. It was either stupid or arrogant to explain it before playing.
Marcus Smith’s Role
Now, with Marcus Smith on the bench, there is a chance of change if things go wrong. Smith can run, pass, and kick in ways that might force Scotland’s defense to change its pattern. His inclusion signifies England’s acknowledgment that one game plan alone is not enough.
The Selection Gamble
Smith’s selection for Edinburgh set the tone for Borthwick’s approach: England will face Ireland with more options than blind faith in their prescribed strategy. If they are dominant, Smith might not see much playing time. But if Ireland cannot scrum up effectively, Smith could be the difference.
Lessons from 2022
In 2022, Marcus Smith made his Six Nations debut at Murrayfield, overcame a nervy start, and dominated the second half with a blind-side try that put England on top. Jones’ decision to substitute him for George Ford after he had taken charge was a classic case of missing an opportunity.
A Necessary Change
England’s strategy in Edinburgh was flawed because it lacked flexibility. By including Smith, Borthwick is showing foresight. If the initial plan doesn’t work, having someone with the ability to change the game could be crucial.
